Laura Parkinson (stormfeather) wrote,
Laura Parkinson
stormfeather

Parasha: Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: December 23rd reading


Probably will be briefish this time. Almost forgot this!

Note that Watson just vaguely mentions his old war wound in "one of his limbs," possibly because at one point it was supposed to be his shoulder, and at another, his leg. Maybe Doyle didn't want to try to pick which was right and thus have another be wrong?

"This looks like one of those unwelcome social summonses which call upon a man either to be bored or to lie." Hah! One of those moments when Holmes seems quite human.

Whee, more of those exotic and whacky Americans!

The Lord in the case is somewhat sympathetic because of what happened to him... but not so much, otherwise. Thinking his poor delicate little flower of a wife got a bit unhinged at the sheer awe of marrying him, frex. Yeesh.

The Holmes cases do at least show variety... while last one was almost all story and no actual deduction, here again we have mostly deduction, and little in the way of action.

I'll also admit, I tend to think of the slang as "what's up" as more modern, and American, surely not something that Holmes would use! ("What's up, then?" when Lestrade enters the room to consult with him.)

I will also mention that it is a bit annoying though that it seems like every case has to have a red herring in the form of some coincidence - here, the "F.H.M" as initials.

Anyhow, I think that about does it for my comments! Discuss away!


Oh hai schedule!
Tags: books, parasha, parasha_holmes
Subscribe

  • Booklist meme (aka the NPR Top 100 SFF books)

    Since I got reminded about this this morning by seeing it on silmaril's journal, I'll finally get around to doing this again, after…

  • Lyrics Meme: Answers

    Sorry, running a bit late on these! The ones in italics were the ones that were guessed, and the person that guessed them comes after. The answers…

  • Lyrics Meme Repost

    Oops, let this go longer than intended. Figure I'd give it a quick repost for any stragglers, then post the answers in a day or so. You know the…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments