?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Page | Next Page

Yeep, I almost forgot about today's reading!


Man, that's gotta be weird, sleeping on, y'know, a path rather than tucked away in a camp. It's also gotta be tricky not to leave the path for everything! At least they're all male, if you get the picture...

Also, it's tough to get any picture of just how long they're in the forest. Just the "days following days" and all.

"Black as a top-hat"? Really? Why a top-hat?

And they can't see 12 yards? I'll assume it's because of the blackness, and/or some unmentioned mist or something. Or else dwarves have really really bad eyesight above ground!

Black deer and white deer, very symbolic of something, I'm sure. Didn't a white hart figure into the legend of King Arthur, somewhere? Also, I was somewhat expecting the trip across the river to end up like one of those puzzles: You have to get 13 dwarves and a hobbit across the river in the least number of trips, it will only hold so many dwarves, yadda yadda. But instead of sending someone back with it, they keep throwing the rope across and back. Oh wells.

You'd think Beorn could have told them though, "take heart, for when you see the enchanted stream, you'll be almost out of the woods!"

Anyone else wondering if they would have eaten Bombur, if he hadn't chosen just then to woke up? Well, maybe not in a children's book...

And OF COURSE they leave the path. Like we didn't know they would, after Dire Warnings not to. Although at least I guess staving off starvation is a decent reason for it.

Meanie meanie elves! Bogarting all the food, and not helping travelers in trouble! Hrmph. Not to mention the taking of prisoners later on...

And woot, we get to see Bilbo kicking some butt for the first time. I mean, he did well enough in the goblin caves, but he didn't really *fight*. But now he's all Bilbo the Spider-Slayer! And on an empty stomach, to boot.

Attercop is apparently an "English dialect word" for spider, according to Wiki Pete.

And I'd say the dwarves are darn lucky none of them were dead, what with spider poison + possible suffocation!

Wood Elves vs. High Elves... how very D&D. Although the whole hoarding of treasure thing seems out of place.



And for Wednesday, Chapters 9 and 10.

Comments

( 8 Notes — Write a Footnote )
(Deleted comment)
stormfeather
Sep. 17th, 2012 08:38 pm (UTC)
Well, they've got to be able to eat SOMETHING I guess, without it kicking up a sapient ruckus! (Now I'm flashing back to Through the Looking Glass, if you've read that... and also Restaurant at the End of the Universe.)
(Deleted comment)
(Deleted comment)
vizsludraugas
Sep. 18th, 2012 01:14 am (UTC)
"Black as a top hat" wasn't an uncommon saying in the UK in Tolkien's youth: H.G Well uses it in The Invisible Man.

The elves in this bit are a bit more like they are in English, Scots and Irish legend, mischievous and a bit mean. Leading travellers astray was one of their favorite tricks in those legends. And they have not gone into the West..to Fairie, which is a major difference from LOTR.

And so Sting gains its name-I'd forgotten exactly how that happened. We also see hobbit stone throwing for the first time, although here it seems to be something Bilbo is good at, not necessarily a skill common to hobbits in general.

Attercop is a dialect word, and it's also very close to the Old English word for spider.
(Deleted comment)
(Deleted comment)
khedron
Sep. 18th, 2012 12:23 pm (UTC)
Oh no, we brought the wrong halfling!
( 8 Notes — Write a Footnote )